Do We Really Love Animals—or Only Certain Animals?

Pets, Hunting, Children, and the Complicated Boundaries of Human Compassion

By Dr. Vijay Kumar

I have two dogs.

Like many people who live with dogs, I don’t think of them simply as animals living in my house. They have personalities. They communicate in their own ways. They become excited, frightened, comfortable, anxious and affectionate. I know their routines and behaviors, and they certainly know mine.

They are part of my family.

If one of my dogs were injured, I would immediately try to help.

If someone deliberately hurt one of them, I would be deeply disturbed.

And if someone intentionally shot and killed one of my dogs, I cannot imagine simply accepting it as the death of an animal.

Yet this very relationship with my dogs has led me to think about something that I find increasingly difficult to reconcile.

I know people who genuinely love dogs and cats, yet also hunt.

They may cuddle their dog in the morning, worry when their cat isn’t feeling well, spend thousands of dollars on veterinary treatment—and then go into the woods to shoot a deer, elk, bear or another wild animal.

I am not writing this article to condemn those people.

I am not trying to declare hunters cruel.

Instead, I am trying to understand something about all of us:

When we say that we love animals, do we really mean animals—or do we mean certain animals?

Perhaps our compassion toward animals is much more selective than we realize.

The Dead Deer That Made Me Think

Living in Michigan, I have seen plenty of deer.

Unfortunately, I have also seen many dead deer.

Sometimes they have been struck by vehicles. During hunting season, hunting itself becomes part of the culture and conversation around us.

There is something about seeing a dead deer that affects me.

I see the blood.

I see the eyes.

Sometimes I see moisture around the eyes that looks remarkably like tears.

And I find myself thinking:

This was alive.

Only a short time earlier, this animal could run. It could react to danger. Its nervous system could process injury. It sought food and shelter and responded to the environment around it.

When I look at that animal and then think about my two dogs, I struggle with the distinction we have created.

If the animal lying there were someone’s Labrador retriever, our emotional reaction might be completely different.

Why?

Are Those Really Tears?

Here I think it is important to distinguish emotional reaction from scientific evidence.

Seeing moisture around a deer’s eyes does not prove that the deer was emotionally crying in the way humans cry from grief, fear or sadness.

Many mammals produce tears because tears lubricate and protect the eye.

Therefore, I would not scientifically claim that every deer I have seen with wet eyes was "crying."

But that clarification should not lead us to the opposite conclusion—that a deer is incapable of suffering.

Those are two entirely different questions.

The evidence that mammals possess the neurological machinery necessary to experience pain is substantial. Animal-welfare science and veterinary medicine recognize pain and distress in mammals, even though we cannot ask an animal to verbally describe what it is experiencing.

We don’t require our dogs to speak English before believing that they hurt when injured.

Why should another mammal have to demonstrate human-like emotional crying before its suffering matters?

Deer Are Not Objects

Sometimes our language itself creates emotional distance.

We call a dog "Buddy."

We call a deer "game."

One has a name.

The other has a category.

But the animal doesn’t know which category humans have assigned to it.

Deer have nervous systems. They respond to danger and injury. They display physiological stress responses and complex behaviors.

That does not mean a deer experiences the world exactly as a human does.

It also doesn’t mean that a deer thinks exactly like my dogs.

We should be careful about anthropomorphizing animals.

But avoiding anthropomorphism shouldn’t mean denying biology.

A deer doesn’t have to think like us to experience pain.

A bear doesn’t have to think like us to experience distress.

An elk doesn’t have to understand mortality philosophically for its life to matter biologically.

It Isn’t Only About Deer

Deer started this thought process for me because they are the animals I encounter most frequently.

But my question goes far beyond deer.

People hunt elk.

People hunt bears.

People hunt turkey and waterfowl.

People hunt numerous other species depending upon location, regulations and tradition.

Here in Michigan, deer, elk and bear hunting are regulated activities, with specific seasons, licenses, harvest rules and other requirements.

Therefore, this isn’t really a question about one species.

It is a question about how humans categorize animals.

The Categories We Create

Think about the different categories into which we place animals.

A dog becomes a pet.

A cat becomes a companion.

A cow becomes livestock.

A chicken becomes food.

A laboratory mouse becomes a research animal.

A rat entering our home becomes a pest.

A deer or elk becomes game.

A bear can become game or a magnificent wildlife encounter, depending upon the circumstances.

These categories dramatically influence our emotional reactions.

Imagine someone posting a photograph online showing a dog they had just deliberately shot.

Most people would probably be horrified.

Now imagine someone posting a photograph standing beside a deer they legally harvested during hunting season.

Many people congratulate them.

The biological event is similar in one fundamental respect:

A living mammal has been intentionally killed.

But culturally, the two events mean very different things.

Why?

Perhaps Love Is Built on Relationship

One answer may simply be relationship.

My dogs aren’t anonymous animals to me.

I know them.

They know me.

We share a history.

When one looks at me, there is a relationship behind that look.

A deer standing 100 yards away doesn’t have that relationship with me.

I don’t know where it slept last night.

I don’t know whether it has offspring nearby.

I don’t recognize its individual behavior.

It remains simply "a deer."

That emotional distance may make killing psychologically easier.

This phenomenon isn’t limited to hunters.

Almost all of us categorize animals.

Many people who would never hunt eat meat.

They may love their dogs while eating beef, chicken, pork or fish without thinking very much about the animals from which those foods originated.

So perhaps hunters aren’t uniquely inconsistent.

Perhaps human beings are inconsistent in our relationship with animals generally.

Hunting Deserves a Fair Discussion

I don’t want this article to become an attack on hunters because doing so would prevent us from asking the deeper question.

There are many reasons people hunt.

Some hunt for food.

Some grew up hunting with parents and grandparents.

Some see it as an important family tradition.

Some enjoy spending time outdoors.

Some view hunting as part of wildlife management.

Some hunters take the ethical responsibility of minimizing suffering very seriously.

Some use virtually every usable portion of an animal.

And some hunt because they enjoy the challenge or sporting element.

Those motivations shouldn’t automatically be treated as identical.

Many hunters would also reject the suggestion that they don’t care about animals.

Some hunters probably spend more time studying wildlife, habitat, animal behavior and conservation than many people who describe themselves as animal lovers.

That deserves acknowledgment.

Hunting and Conservation

There is also an important conservation argument.

Regulated hunting is integrated into wildlife-management systems in the United States. Hunting licenses and hunting-related programs contribute financially to wildlife management, habitat work and conservation.

There are also circumstances in which wildlife populations must be managed because ecosystems have changed dramatically through human development, agriculture, roads, habitat fragmentation and altered predator populations.

So the debate cannot honestly be reduced to:

Hunters hate animals and nonhunters love them.

Reality is considerably more complicated.

Someone can care deeply about wildlife and still believe regulated hunting has a legitimate role in conservation.

Someone else can accept the need for wildlife management while questioning whether recreational killing should be celebrated.

Both questions deserve discussion.

But One Word Still Bothers Me: "Sport"

Perhaps the part I personally struggle with most is when killing a living animal is described primarily as sport.

Food is one argument.

Population management is another.

Conservation is another.

Subsistence hunting is another.

But killing primarily for entertainment raises a different ethical question for me.

When the ultimate measure of success requires another living creature to die, I think it is reasonable to ask what we mean by recreation.

Again, I am asking the question rather than claiming there is one answer everyone must accept.

But it is a question worth asking.

Then There Are the Children

This brings me to the part of this subject that concerns me most.

Children can be introduced to hunting at surprisingly young ages.

I have seen young people around 12, 13 and 14 years old participating in hunting.

And I wonder:

At what age is a child emotionally prepared to intentionally take the life of another sentient creature?

This question is different from whether a child can learn how to operate a firearm safely.

It is different from whether hunting is legal.

It is different from whether a child understands the mechanics of hunting.

I am asking about emotional and moral development.

Michigan Allows Youth Hunting

Michigan’s hunting regulations include youth participation under specified conditions.

For example, qualifying youth can participate in designated youth hunting opportunities, while Michigan’s Mentored Hunting Program also provides opportunities for younger participants under adult supervision and applicable rules.

That establishes what the law permits.

But legality doesn’t completely answer my question.

When should a child emotionally participate in taking a life?

Children Understand More Than We Sometimes Think

We shouldn’t underestimate children.

Children’s understanding of death develops progressively through childhood.

A child may understand that death is permanent and that a dead animal will not return.

But cognitive understanding isn’t necessarily the same thing as emotional readiness.

A child can understand what death means without necessarily being prepared to experience the responsibility of causing it.

Two 12-Year-Olds Are Not the Same

One 12-year-old may have grown up on a farm.

Another may never have seen a dead animal.

One may have accompanied parents hunting for years.

Another may be extremely sensitive to blood.

One may genuinely want to hunt.

Another may simply desperately want Dad’s approval.

That last distinction particularly interests me.

Imagine a father, mother, grandfather or older sibling who is passionate about hunting.

The child admires that adult.

The adult says:

"You’re finally old enough. This year you’re going to get your first deer."

The child may say yes.

But what does that yes mean?

Does it mean:

"I have thought about killing an animal and genuinely want to do it"?

Or could it sometimes mean:

"I want you to be proud of me"?

Those are psychologically very different motivations.

A Child Should Be Allowed to Lower the Gun

Imagine this situation.

A parent and a 13-year-old child have spent hours waiting.

Finally, a deer appears.

The child raises the rifle.

The animal is standing within range.

Everything is legal.

The parent whispers that the child can take the shot.

But while looking through the sight, the child hesitates.

Then lowers the rifle.

What should happen next?

I believe this is an important moment in the discussion.

The child should be allowed to say:

"I don’t want to kill it."

Without humiliation.

Without being called weak.

Without being told to toughen up.

Without having masculinity, courage or maturity questioned.

Because choosing not to pull a trigger is also a decision.

What Happens After the Shot?

Hunting doesn’t end when someone pulls the trigger.

The animal may fall immediately.

Or it may run.

It may be wounded.

There can be blood.

The hunter may have to track it.

Occasionally another shot may be necessary.

Then comes recovery of the animal.

And, when the animal is being used for food, field dressing and processing.

A child participating in this experience may see blood, internal organs, skinning, dismemberment and the transformation of an animal into meat.

For some children raised around hunting or farming, this may be familiar.

For others it may be extremely intense.

Neither reaction automatically tells us something is wrong with the child.

Is Butchering an Animal Necessarily Worse Than Buying Meat?

This is another place where people who oppose hunting should examine their own assumptions.

If I buy meat from a supermarket, an animal still died.

The difference is that I didn’t see it.

Someone else performed the killing and processing.

The meat arrives cleaned, cut and packaged.

There are no eyes.

There is no blood.

There is no visible animal.

In that respect, a hunter who kills a deer, processes it and feeds a family may actually be more directly confronted with the consequences of eating meat than the supermarket consumer.

That doesn’t automatically make hunting ethically right or wrong.

But it reveals another contradiction in our relationship with animals.

Does Hunting Teach Children Violence?

This question also requires caution.

It would be irresponsible to make the simplistic claim:

"Children who hunt become violent adults."

Human behavior doesn’t work that way, and such a sweeping conclusion cannot be justified simply from the fact that a child participates in hunting.

Context matters.

Teaching a child firearm safety, wildlife laws, responsibility, conservation, food procurement and avoidance of unnecessary suffering is not psychologically equivalent to teaching a child to enjoy cruelty.

That distinction is extremely important.

Killing and cruelty are not automatically synonymous.

Cruelty involves unnecessary suffering or indifference to suffering.

Ethically practiced hunting generally emphasizes making an effective shot and minimizing unnecessary suffering.

We can debate whether hunting itself is morally acceptable while still recognizing that distinction.

But Neither Should We Teach Emotional Numbness

My concern is different.

If a child feels sadness after killing an animal, what do we teach that child?

Do we say:

"Don’t worry about it."

"It’s only a deer."

"You’ll get used to it."

Or do we say:

"What are you feeling?"

Perhaps sadness after taking a life isn’t weakness.

Perhaps it demonstrates empathy.

And perhaps a child can simultaneously participate in a family hunting tradition and understand the seriousness of what occurred.

Those ideas don’t have to contradict one another.

If We Teach Hunting, Teach Respect First

If parents decide that hunting is appropriate for their children, perhaps the first lesson shouldn’t be how to shoot.

It should be respect for life.

Teach children that the animal isn’t a target in a video game.

Teach them that wounding an animal causes real suffering.

Teach them never to shoot simply because killing feels exciting.

Teach them firearm safety.

Teach them wildlife laws.

Teach them conservation.

Teach them why seasons and harvest limits exist.

Teach them to use the animal responsibly when hunting for food.

Teach them that an ethical shot sometimes means not taking the shot.

And teach them that they always have permission to say:

"I don’t want to kill this animal."

My Dogs Keep Bringing Me Back to the Same Question

Eventually my thoughts return to my two dogs.

I know them.

I love them.

I would protect them.

If they were frightened or injured, their suffering would matter enormously to me.

Then I imagine a deer standing quietly in a Michigan forest.

Or an elk.

Or a bear.

That animal doesn’t know me.

I haven’t given it a name.

It doesn’t sleep inside my house.

But does my lack of relationship with that animal change its capacity to experience pain?

Of course not.

What changes is my emotional relationship with its suffering.

And perhaps that is the distinction I have been trying to understand.

Maybe "Animal Lover" Is More Complicated Than We Think

Perhaps saying "I love animals" is too simple.

Most of us practice some form of selective compassion.

We love dogs but eat pigs.

We rescue cats but kill mice entering our homes.

We admire wildlife but build highways through its habitat.

We condemn someone for hurting a pet while accepting industrial systems that kill animals we never see.

Some of us hunt.

Some eat meat but could never personally kill the animal.

Some refuse to eat animals entirely.

Humans have created an extraordinarily complicated moral relationship with the animal world.

Perhaps the important thing is not pretending those contradictions don’t exist.

It is being willing to examine them.

I Am Not Asking Hunters to Defend Themselves

This isn’t intended as an indictment of hunting families.

I understand that someone reading this may have hunted with a father or grandfather and remember those experiences as some of the most meaningful moments of childhood.

Another person may depend on harvested game for food.

Another may believe strongly that responsible hunting contributes to wildlife conservation.

Another may hunt but feel enormous respect and even sadness after taking an animal.

Those experiences are real.

My experience is real too.

When I see a dead deer—its body, its blood and what appears to my eyes as tears—I feel something.

Science tells me not to assume those tears represent human-like emotional crying.

Fair enough.

But science also tells us enough about mammalian pain and animal behavior that I cannot simply see the animal as an object.

It was alive.

Now it isn’t.

That deserves at least a moment of reflection.

Perhaps the Real Question Is About Compassion

I started with a seemingly simple question:

How can someone love a dog and hunt a deer?

After thinking about it more deeply, I realize that the answer isn’t simple at all.

Relationship matters.

Culture matters.

Food matters.

Tradition matters.

Conservation matters.

Wildlife management matters.

Child development matters.

And personal morality matters.

I don’t expect everyone reading this article to reach the same conclusion I have.

In fact, I am not sure I have reached a final conclusion myself.

But perhaps that is precisely why the conversation matters.

Before we describe ourselves as animal lovers, perhaps we should occasionally ask:

Which animals do I love?

Which animals do I protect?

Which animals do I eat?

Which animals am I willing to kill?

Which animals am I comfortable allowing someone else to kill for me?

And perhaps most importantly:

Why?

For parents introducing children to hunting, I would add one more question:

Before teaching a child how to take a life, are we also teaching that child to understand and respect the value of that life?

Hunting traditions may continue.

People will continue eating meat.

Wildlife will continue to require management.

Families will continue disagreeing about where ethical boundaries should be drawn.

But regardless of which side of the hunting debate we occupy, I hope we can preserve one thing:

Compassion.

Because the ability to take a life should never require us to lose our respect for life.

And perhaps loving animals doesn’t require everyone to arrive at exactly the same answer.

Maybe it begins with being willing to ask ourselves the difficult questions.

Author Note

This article is a personal reflection on animals, compassion, hunting, family traditions and the difficult ethical questions surrounding our relationship with other living beings.

It is not intended to condemn hunters, promote or oppose hunting, or provide legal or psychological advice. Laws and hunting regulations vary by jurisdiction and can change over time. The purpose of this reflection is simply to encourage thoughtful conversation about compassion, responsibility, respect for wildlife and how we teach children to understand the value of life.

— Dr. Vijay Kumar